The 8 Best Peanut Butters You Need to Try in 2025
WELLNESS
The 7 Best Peanut Butters You Need to Try
Okay, let's get real for a second. Is there anything better than a spoonful of rich, creamy peanut butter? Personally, I doubt it. But if you’ve tried to buy some recently, you know the struggle is real. The market is packed with options, and it’s tough to figure out which one is actually worth your money.
That's why I chose to look for the best options available right now. I've looked at a lot of different peanut butter brands on the market and tried some of the most popular and up-and-coming ones. I can help you whether you like a good crunch or a smooth finish. These are my top seven picks for 2025. They're great for everything from quick snacks to improving your morning smoothie.
My Go-To Picks for the Perfect Spoonful
1.The Butternut Co. Natural Peanut Butter (Crunchy):
Okay, if you need that satisfying texture as much as I do, this one is for you. You can see and feel the real peanut pieces as soon as you open the jar. The flavour is pure and simple, and it hits the spot. To be honest, it's what I reach for when I want to add some serious crunch to my breakfast or have a quick snack. This peanut butter is best for heart health because it doesn't have any added salt and is cholesterol-free. It's also great for people who are trying to cut back on sodium.
2.Asitis Nutrition AS-IT-IS Peanut Butter (Crunchy):
For anyone serious about fitness, Asitis is an absolute must-try. This isn't just another jar of peanut butter; it’s a true peanut butter with no unwanted ingredients. Just 100% roasted peanuts that help you refuel after a tough workout. It’s pure, clean, and has a robust, nutty flavour. If you’re looking for a crunchy peanut butter to get more protein in your diet, this is it.
3.MyFitness Peanut Butter (Smooth):
This is the jar I reach for when I want pure, creamy indulgence. It's so unbelievably smooth that it melts in your mouth! This is hands down one of the best smooth peanut butter brands I've found. If you're looking for the best peanut butter for smoothies, this brand is a fantastic choice; it blends seamlessly and gives you that perfect, rich flavour without any fuss.
4.Trubite Natural Peanut Butter (Crunchy):
This is the jar I reach for when I want pure, creamy indulgence. It's so unbelievably smooth that it melts in your mouth! This is hands down one of the best smooth peanut butter brands I've found. If you're looking for the best peanut butter for smoothies, this brand is a fantastic choice; it blends seamlessly and gives you that perfect, rich flavour without any fuss.
5.The Whole Truth Peanut Butter:
I have to give a huge shoutout to The Whole Truth. This brand is a game-changer. For anyone trying to cut back on sugar, this no-added-sugar peanut butter is simply the best option out there. It tastes fantastic, allowing the natural, slightly sweet flavour of the peanuts to shine. It’s a guilt-free pleasure, and it is one of my absolute favourites for spreading on toast.
6.Alpino Natural Peanut Butter:
Alpino is a name you’ve probably heard, and for good reason they do it right. Their natural peanut butter has a reliable, balanced taste and a smooth, easy-to-spread consistency. It's the kind of staple you can keep in your pantry for any occasion, from a classic peanut butter and jam to a quick dollop in your oatmeal.
7.Beastlife Natural Peanut Butter:
Another excellent peanut butter choice is Beastlife. This one is for people who are into fitness. It has a lot of flavour and is very thick and filling. It's the best fuel for a busy day because it gives you energy when you need it most. It's a strong machine that tastes excellent, too!
8.Pintola All Natural Peanut Butter:
Another good choice with a 4.3 rating on Amazon, it hits your taste buds differently. It's crunchy and unsweetened, and it gives you that extra protein in your smoothie or oatmeal. Honestly, I cannot stop with one spoon, as it's made with 100% roasted peanuts. I just feel there is so much difference peanut butter gets when the peanuts are roasted. Don't you think? If you are someone who likes peanuts roasted then this one is for you
So, here is my personal list of the seven best peanut butters you need to try this year. There is a perfect jar for you, regardless of what you like. Picking a good one can really improve your snacks and make your favourite dishes taste even better. Now, if you will excuse me, I think I need to go get a spoon. Before I go, always remember to choose peanut butter that is made with only peanuts and no extra sugars, oils, or other ingredients.
(This blog post is a personal review and guide. We only display the pictures for illustrative purposes, sourced from the brands' websites. This post is not paid for, and its goal is to promote these excellent brands and give readers useful information. The links are Amazon affiliate links, which give me a tiny commission if you buy, without you paying anything extra. We don't own the pictures, and we want to respect all copyrights.)